Paperback: 242 pages
Publisher: YMAA Publication Center; 39127th edition (May 16, 2011)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 1594392137
ISBN-13: 978-1594392139
Product Dimensions: 6.1 x 0.6 x 9.1 inches
Shipping Weight: 9.1 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review: 4.7 out of 5 stars See all reviews (248 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #46,024 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #63 in Books > Sports & Outdoors > Individual Sports > Martial Arts #80 in Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Social Sciences > Violence in Society #725 in Books > Health, Fitness & Dieting > Exercise & Fitness
A while back, I wrote a short facebook status that said "Finished my first read through of Rory Miller's Facing Violence last night. Will be starting a second read through before reviewing it. Short version: if you teach or train self-defense, read this book."Upon a second reading, my views have not changed substantively. Facing Violence is an extremely important book, and anyone who has any reason to want to understand how to deal with violence should read it. Martial artists and self-defense instructors will get the most value out of it, but it has ideas that are useful for LEO and Military Combatives trainers as well.Facing Violence is broken into seven chapters:1. Legal and ethical implications.2. Violence dynamics.3. Avoidance.4. Counter-ambush.5. Breaking the freeze.6. The fight itself.7. The aftermath.The astute out there will notice that the book takes three chapters to even get to any kind of physical assault, and another two dealing with what is essentially the first micro second of the fight (the ambush moment). There is only a single chapter about the fight itself, despite the fact that that single chapter is where most martial artists spend the vast majority of their training time. Think about how backwards that is for a minute. Maybe longer.The chapter on legal and ethical implications of violence is interesting. The legal advice is, by necessity, a bit generic, and Rory advises readers to check up on their local statutes. "A book I read by a guy from the Wet Coast said this was okay" is not a valid legal defense.
And I really do mean EVERYONE. Not just martial artists or self-defense instructors, although they should DEFINITELY read this book. In fact, anyone who teaches self-defense who doesn't read this book is doing their students a huge, and potentially dangerous, disservice. The material held within is a game changer, and if a martial arts instructor is not covering these seven topics, they need to either (a) figure out a way to incorporate them into their curriculum or (b) remove the phrases "self-defense" and "self-protection" from all of their marketing material.But that's just from the instructors' side. As I said, everyone should read this book. Why? Because only the smallest bit of self-protection is actually the physical skills that people think of when they consider the martial arts. Going through the book's chapters, there is (1) Legal and Ethical, (2) Violence Dynamics, (3) Avoidance, (4) Counter-Ambush, (5) The Freeze, (6) The Fight, and (7) After. Note that only two or three of these involve any traditional, "fighting" skills. In addition, if someone is good at the first three, the odds of ever making it to (4) are markedly reduced. To play on an old cliché, that's the true power of this book - the knowledge that it gives to the reader. Anyone, and I mean anyone, who reads this book will gain practical knowledge and easy-to-implement tips and behaviors that will make them MUCH safer. (And to all of you guys out there, get your significant other to read this book. I realize that it might be a hard sell, but it may well be the single most important thing you can do to enhance their safety. Remember, you aren't necessarily going to be around when bad things happen.
I am not an attorney, and none of the following is an offer of legal advice.This is a great book. I would recommend it with the very same eagerness with books that I give the best score. Now, there is a reason why I only gave it 3 stars. The readers need to know what this book is and what it is not. The cover where a two peaceful couple is confronted by a person armed with a knife is kind of misleading, as you'll find that the book is not really about street crime avoidance guide(more on this later). It's more of a study of mental aspects of violence, and a pretty introspective one at that.You will find the author taking a lot of space to describe a process of two or more parties getting into a conflict and mutually escalating it to physical violence because of their ego. He calls the process "monkey dance." That starts from the part that explains dynamics of violence, but it extends well into avoidance section of the book, and is a recurring theme thorough out the book. I find mainly two problems with the way author handles the "monkey dance." First problem is that considering the weight the author is giving it, it does not help anyone who is trying to seek a way to avoid crime that happens as no fault of their own. Someone saying "Don't get into fights because of your ego" won't help someone trying to avoid a robbery or kidnapping(which is why I find the cover picture kind of misleading, but the picture was probably not the author's idea). Now, the author does offer other guides to avoid such crimes. But, although I did learn a few tips that helps with my insight about criminals, it was kind of generic for the most part. The second problem is that the author's definition of "monkey dance" is overly broad.
Facing Violence: Preparing for the Unexpected An Unexpected Passion (Unexpected Series Book 2) An Unexpected Proposal (Unexpected Series Book 1) Preparing Children for Court: A Practitioner's Guide (Interpersonal Violence: the Practice Series) Preparing and Presenting Expert Testimony in Child Abuse Litigation: A Guide for Expert Witnesses and Attorneys (Interpersonal Violence: The Practice Series) Everyday Revolutionaries: Gender, Violence, and Disillusionment in Postwar El Salvador (Genocide, Political Violence, Human Rights) The Batterer as Parent: Addressing the Impact of Domestic Violence on Family Dynamics (SAGE Series on Violence against Women) Meditations on Violence: A Comparison of Martial Arts Training & Real World Violence Keeping the Faith: Guidance for Christian Women Facing Abuse Facing the Facts: The Truth About Sex and You (God's Design for Sex, Book 4) Whatever the Cost: Facing Your Fears, Dying to Your Dreams, and Living Powerfully Facing Death Together: Parish Funerals Tiger Heart: My Unexpected Adventures to Make a Difference in Darjeeling, and What I Learned about Fate, Fortitude, and Finding Family Half a World Away An Unexpected Cookbook: The Unofficial Book of Hobbit Cookery The Art of Mistakes: Unexpected Painting Techniques and the Practice of Creative Thinking The Unexpected Houseplant: 220 Extraordinary Choices for Every Spot in Your Home The Unlikely Lavender Queen: A Memoir of Unexpected Blossoming Just in Case: How to be Self-Sufficient when the Unexpected Happens Facing the Promotional Interview Diabetes Lifestyle Book: Facing Your Fears and Making Changes for a Long and Healthy Life