Paperback: 96 pages
Publisher: Vintage; 1st Vintage Books ed edition (May 27, 1997)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 067977646X
ISBN-13: 978-0679776468
Product Dimensions: 5.1 x 0.3 x 8 inches
Shipping Weight: 4.8 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review: 3.8 out of 5 stars See all reviews (15 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #302,793 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #225 in Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Politics & Government > International & World Politics > Russian & Former Soviet Union #404 in Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Politics & Government > Ideologies & Doctrines > Communism & Socialism #437 in Books > Textbooks > Social Sciences > Political Science > Political History
As well as completely changing the political and geographical structure of Europe, the demise of the Soviet Union has significantly altered the approach of historical scholarship about the Russian Revolution.In Three Whys of the Russian Revolution, the eminent scholar of Russian history, Richard Pipes, confronts the challenge of assessing the causes and course of the Russian Revolutions from a post-Cold War perspective.Pipes explains that for 70 years prior to the 1990's, historians in the West adopted a "revisionist" perspective of the Russian Revolutions that was largely influenced by Communist scholarship. The events of 1917, these Communist scholars concluded, were nothing but revolutionary activity.Western scholarship's acceptance of this conclusion stems, Pipes explains, from a lack of source material, much of which was deemed classified by the Soviet regime.But access to this information is now open, and Pipes, among others, has utilized this opportunity in an attempt to re-evaluate the Revolutions, with the product being two extensive works (on which these essays are based). Not surprisingly, his understanding of the events of 1917 has changed somewhat, and thus the three essays in the book are a continued attempt to debunk much of the "revisionist" perspective with less radical conclusions.Among the notions that Pipes challenges is the very insistence by the "revisionists" that the Revolutions were in fact revolutions.As the author clearly outlines, the events of 1917 were actually the work of a small group of intellectuals headed by the idealist Lenin. His overthrow of the Czarist regime is argued by Pipes as being a coup d'etat which involved the people as a whole in only a small degree.
When was the Russian Revolution? The conventional answer would be October 1917. After all, people associate Lenin with the October Revolution, don't they? Well, Mr. Pipes (amongst an increasing group of others) would stop you right there. Upon the tsar's abdication Russia's first free elections (promised since that February) were held November 12, 1917. This was but days after Lenin's Bolsheviks supposedly "rode to power on a wave of popular support," yet Lenin's ilk only received enought votes to garner 175 seats out of 707! The Bolshevik takeover was more akin to a putsch, consequently. Trotsky himself wrote (in his memoirs) "that 25,000 or 30,000 people, at most, took part in the events of October in Petrograd"; this in a city of 2 million. It was largely bloodless and basically upended the hopelessly incompetent Provisional Government in the dead of one night in favor of the Petersburg Council---or "Soviet," to utilize the Russian word for council. And it was through this organ of competing power that Lenin was able to forestall Russian military units from marching in to St. Petersburg to resist him. In January when Russia's first Constituent Assemby opened Lenin immediately proposed a motion that would have prevented the duly elected Assembly from wielding any real power over the Petersburg Soviet, or any of the other Soviets in other cities. Lenin's Bolsheviks were handedly defeated in this, however; which marked the end of democracy in Russia. The next day Bolshevik Red Guards closed down the Assembly and it was never permitted to sit again. How Lenin was able to engineer this is the subject of the second part of this tri-part (extremely concise & worthy) mini-book of 84 pages. Pipes shows, in addition, how nothing of this was at all inevitable.
Three "Whys" of the Russian Revolution The Russian Word's Worth: A Humorous and Informative Guide to Russian Language Culture and Translation (New Russian Writing) Russian Classics in Russian and English: Notes from Underground by Fyodor Dostoevsky (Dual-Language Book) (Russian Edition) Making Sense of Phonics, Second Edition: The Hows and Whys Classic Russian Cooking: Elena Molokhovets' a Gift to Young Housewives (Indiana-Michigan Series in Russian & East European Studies) Russian Easy Food Recipes - Russian Zakuski: Snack Foods Two Vocal Works, Op. 52, 53: Russian, English Language Edition (Kalmus Edition) (Russian Edition) Songs, Op. 49, 50, 51, Vol 6: Russian, English Language Edition (Kalmus Edition) (Russian Edition) The Tsar's Bride: Vocal Score (Russian Language Edition) (Vocal Score) (Kalmus Edition) (Russian Edition) Songs, Op. 41, 42, 43, Vol 4: Russian, English Language Edition (Kalmus Edition) (Russian Edition) Five Operas and a Symphony: Word and Music in Russian Culture (Russian Literature and Thought Series) Ten Russian Folk Song, Two Russian Folk Song Op. 104 Vocal Score (Shostakovich Complete Edition) Russian Futurism: A History (Russian History and Culture) Contemporary Russian Poetry: An Anthology (Russian Edition) Russian Stories: A Dual-Language Book (English and Russian Edition) War & Peace: Contemporary Russian Prose (New Russian Writing) Russkie narodnye skazki - Russian Folk Tales (Russian Edition) Dermo!: The Real Russian Tolstoy Never Used (Russian Edition) The Everything Learning Russian Book with CD: Speak, write, and understand Russian in no time! On Spiritual Unity: A Slavophile Reader (Library of Russian Philosophy.) (Esalen-Lindisfarne Library of Russian Philosophy)