Paperback: 365 pages
Publisher: Palgrave Macmillan; 1st edition (2013)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 1137281650
ISBN-13: 978-1137281654
Product Dimensions: 5.3 x 0.9 x 8.5 inches
Shipping Weight: 1.1 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review: 4.7 out of 5 stars See all reviews (53 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #383,465 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #83 in Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Politics & Government > Ideologies & Doctrines > Anarchism #260 in Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Philosophy > Social Philosophy #442 in Books > Textbooks > Social Sciences > Political Science > Political Ideologies
The book is a gem, destined to become a classic, and any serious student of the field should have it on their shelf. They should even, dare I say, read it.The topic that Humer’s astonishing tour de force concerns itself with is the moral and ethical underpinnings of state power, an area known in political philosophy as the "problem of political authority".In considering the justification for the state, a nagging question naturally arises. Most people would claim it is morally impermissible for your neighbor to force you to give money to a charity of his choice at gunpoint. However, in stark contrast, most people would claim it is permissible for the state to do essentially the same thing, that is, to extort taxes from you using the threat of force in order to spend those funds on projects other than your own.Most people appear to claim there is an important difference between these cases — otherwise, they would not believe in the legitimacy of the state.The eponymous problem of political authority is the question of what the distinction between these cases might be — on what basis, if any, might we justify this difference in treatment between the behavior we consider ethically justified from individual actors versus the power we accord to the state.Huemer systematically addresses the justifications that have been articulated for political authority over the centuries, from hypothetical social contract theory to consequentialism and everything in between. I will give away the punchline by noting that his arguments would appear to fatally damage all of them.Political philosophers often start by attempting to construct a complete moral framework within which they justify their positions.
Michael Huemer starts his thinking in political authority in a good, but uncommon, spot: by asking whether the very idea of political authority has anything to be said for it. Most political philosophy either bypasses the entire question of whether political authority is justified (by asking what government is best), or by asking where political authority comes from (assuming that there is such thing as political authority). Huemer's question: is there any good argument for the idea that some have the right to rule over or coerce others? His answer: no good reason exists to justify the idea of political authority.Here's the question in a nutshell: is there anything government (of any kind) does that wouldn't be judged morally wrong if done by private actors? (For instance, can I decide that some of your property is mine because I decided to keep you safe, or promise to spend the money to do good for others, or because most of your community decided that way?) Huemer rehearses several commonly heard justifications of why government actors have the right too coerce (where privvate actors don't): namely, real social contracts, hypothetical social contracts, democratic legitimacy, and utilitarian legitimacy.The idea that government literally began as a social contract is clearly wanting: not only do we have no record of any such social contracts ever taking place (yes, even in the United States), but real contracts have no power to bind anyone but the signers. Hypothetical contracts suffer from (a) the fact that they are completely hypothetical and depict people under very ideal (and dubious) conditions, and (b) suffer from some of the problems of postulating a real social contract (was anyone ever free to opt out or not sign without very difficult consequences, etc?).
The Problem of Political Authority: An Examination of the Right to Coerce and the Duty to Obey The Duty to Obey the Law: Selected Philosophical Readings Standard Catalog of American Light-Duty Trucks: Pickups, Panels, Vans, All Models 1896-2000 (Standard Catalog of American Light-Duty Trucks, 1896-2000) I Give You Authority: Practicing the Authority Jesus Gave Us Pufendorf: On the Duty of Man and Citizen according to Natural Law (Cambridge Texts in the History of Political Thought) Shooting Back - The Right and Duty of Self-Defense Hegel: Lectures on Natural Right and Political Science: The First Philosophy of Right CAT TRAINING FOR HUMANS: OBEY THE CAT RULES OR THERE WILL BE TROUBLE: CAT CARE CAT FOOD CAT BEHAVOUR CAT RULES CAT TRAINING EXPLAINED FOR HUMANS (IT IS ... FOOD CAT LOVER CAT TRAINING SERIES Book 1) Determined to Obey (The Dark Duet) Encyclopedia of Counseling: Master Review and Tutorial for the National Counselor Examination, State Counseling Exams, and the Counselor Preparation Comprehensive Examination Bates' Guide to Physical Examination and History-Taking (Bates Guide to Physical Examination and History Taking) Bates' Guide to Physical Examination and History-Taking 11th Edition TestBank: Test Bank with Rationales for the book Bates' Guide to Physical Examination and History-Taking Seidel's Guide to Physical Examination, 8e (Mosby's Guide to Physical Examination) Obstetrics: Normal and Problem Pregnancies (Obstetrics Normal and Problem Preqnancies) Overcoming Problem Gambling - A guide for problem and compulsive gamblers (Overcoming Common Problems) Automatic Control Systems / Robotics Problem Solver (Problem Solvers Solution Guides) Sovereign Power and the Enlightenment: Eighteenth-Century Literature and the Problem of the Political (Transits: Literature, Thought & Culture, 1650-1850) Marines and Military Law in Vietnam: Trial by Fire - Legal Duty in Combat Zone, War Crime Conviction, POWs, Drugs, Fragging and Murder, Homicide on Patrol, Racial Conflict, Deserters, Uniform Code VA Disability Claim: A Practical, Step-By-Step Field Manual for Active-Duty Servicemembers and Veterans on How to Prepare, File, Maintain, Win and ... VA Disability Claim Without Going Insane Ford Super Duty F-250 & F-350 Pick-ups 1999 Thru 2010: Includes Gasoline and Diesel Engines (Haynes Repair Manual)