Paperback: 184 pages
Publisher: Dawn Sign Press; Expanded edition (August 1993)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0915035200
ISBN-13: 978-0915035205
Product Dimensions: 1.8 x 8.5 x 11.2 inches
Shipping Weight: 12.6 ounces
Average Customer Review: 3.8 out of 5 stars See all reviews (48 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #165,447 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #81 in Books > Reference > Words, Language & Grammar > Sign Language #263 in Books > Textbooks > Communication & Journalism > Communications #498 in Books > Reference > Words, Language & Grammar > Communication
There ARE things I like about this daunting gray book. It's well-organized, and it is very true to the idea of ASL as a language as well as to key concepts of Deaf culture. The DVD contains no speech or sound whatsoever and features actual deaf individuals sharing conversations in ASL, which, in itself, is a good thing.That said, this is probably not a course you can just pick up on your own.And even with classroom instruction to complement the book and DVD, I have seen many students become discouraged by the rapid pace of the signing on the DVD, along with the lack of English translations for vocabulary presented in Signing Naturally. There's no dictionary provided and no way to look up signs as they are learned.Many of the signs shown in the vocabulary sections are not used on the DVD, and it's very hard to figure out ASL just from looking at a picture. Pictures are helpful as a REMINDER, but I personally like to see word lists available, with an index, so the book is useful not only while I'm taking the course but later on - perhaps even many years later.Finally, while the dialogues on the DVD are helpful, there aren't many of them, only two per unit, and they present stilted, artificial situations, and I sense that they don't really inculcate an understanding of how fluent ASL users actually communicate with one another. I did find some of the quizzes on the DVD helpful, however.The individuals involved in the dialogues and quizzes are all very clear and accurate signers, however, they also seem, by and large, either utterly grim and resigned to being part of this dull grey, stripey book.I have read many excellent and FUN books on ASL: this isn't one of them. I've also seen many helpful (often free!
Signing Naturally Student Workbook: Level 1, Expanded Edition Signing Naturally: Student Workbook, Level 1 (Vista American Sign Language: Functional Notation Approach) Signing Naturally: Student Workbook, Units 1-6 (Book & DVDs) REALIDADES 2014 LEVELED VOCABULARY AND GRAMMAR WORKBOOK LEVEL 2 (Realidades: Level 2) REALIDADES 2014 LEVELED VOCABULARY AND GRAMMAR WORKBOOK LEVEL 1 (Realidades: Level 1) ¡Buen viaje! Level 1, Workbook and Audio Activities Student Edition (GLENCOE SPANISH) (Spanish Edition) ¡Avancemos!: Cuaderno: Practica por niveles (Student Workbook) with Review Bookmarks Level 2 (Spanish Edition) ¡Avancemos!: Cuaderno: Practica por niveles (Student Workbook) with Review Bookmarks Level 1 (Spanish Edition) ¡Avancemos!: Cuaderno: Practica por niveles (Student Workbook) with Review Bookmarks Level 3 (Spanish Edition) ¡Avancemos!: Cuaderno para hispanohablantes (Student Workbook) with Review Bookmarks Level 3 (Spanish Edition) A Reason for Handwriting: Level A: Manuscript Student Workbook Teen Health Course 3, Student Activities Workbook Student Edition NJATC Orientation Workbook - Student Workbook 2005 Student Book 2 Student Book with Audio CD and Workbook Pack (Step Forward) Help Yourself Natural Remedies 3 Book Bible: Pro Immunity Anti Inflammatory - Sleep Better Without Meds - Change Your Posture Naturally (Transform Your Life Naturally) Naturally Pain Free: Prevent and Treat Chronic and Acute Pains-Naturally Diabetes Cure: How to Reverse Type 2 Diabetes Naturally with Healthy Food, Diet, and Exercise (Diabetes Diet - Your Ticket to Beating this Disease Naturally and Effectively) Improve Your Eyesight Naturally: How To Improve Your Vision Naturally - Learn Super Effective Eyesight Exercises To Improve Eyesight Without (Vision Therapy, Optometry, Eyesight Improvement) The Joy of Signing (Second Edition) The Joy of Signing: A Dictionary of American Signs, 3rd Edition