Paperback: 128 pages
Publisher: Hill and Wang (September 1, 1983)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0374522073
ISBN-13: 978-0374522070
Product Dimensions: 5.4 x 0.4 x 8 inches
Shipping Weight: 7.2 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review: 4.0 out of 5 stars See all reviews (12 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #173,978 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #18 in Books > Literature & Fiction > History & Criticism > Regional & Cultural > Asian > Japanese #1167 in Books > Literature & Fiction > History & Criticism > Criticism & Theory
It wearies to hear once more that Barthes' "The Empire of Signs" is an example of hypocritical cultural imperialism. It's been said too many times, and further it's an inaccurate assessment of the actual text to begin with. I don't see the need to apologize for this book before recommending it - simply a need to introduce it in terms of what it actually pretends to accomplish as well as what it never imagined it could do. In a word, it's hardly as though Barthes was a Heidegger.As the reviewer mentions, Barthes' shows his hand from the very beginning and does not attempt in the least to produce an objective or scholarly account of Japan. Who could imagine that Barthes, no stranger to genuine historical and anthropological analysis (though he wrote none of his own) would ever have imagined to himself that, here, he could have produced, spontaneously, a passable work of scholarship in a slim volume containing no documentation or critical notes whatsoever?If Barthes is working within any genre at all here, it's not that of scholarship but rather of the essay as first established by Michel de Montaigne. Montaigne's writings on indigenous Brazilians were in no way expected to provide an objective picture, much less construction, of life amongst the cannibals. Montaigne rather finds in the accounts he has heard of the Caribbeans an occasion to reflect on the concerns of his own culture, in particular epistemology, history and the value of the values of civilization. Montaigne was well aware of what he was about, as was Barthes.There is clearly no need to question the merit of thorough anthropological and historical research. However, those disciplines do not exhaust the possibilities of writing on other cultures.
Roland Barthes has, in "The Empire of Signs" described his *experience* in Japan, not Japan-in-itself. To this (subjective) end, the book is fantastic. If you're looking for something more "objective" and/or dry, you'd be better off elsewhere. But this has been said about the book numerous times, and I'm not really contributing anything by repeating it. Instead, I'd like to post a review that actively engages with the text.Throughout this book, Barthes repeatedly finds himself amidst a system which directly contradicts his own in many ways, before returning back to his cleanly-woven fabric of everyday thought to analyze these contradictions. He frequently reaches a kind of baby-like state, where everything he encounters seems to be forced into a pure, senseless presence. This is a common experience to most westerners arriving in Japan. Signs do not seem to be systematized, and seem rather to float freely on an "ocean of nothingness" or something of that nature: an experience that fluctuates between excitement and terror.Actually, this kind of mood reigns wherever there is a true encounter with the external, the unfamiliar, the "other", whether it is an individual person, a culture, or even just a general situation. When our usual system of meaning doesn't work, when it breaks down in the face of a highly discrepant actuality, we become infants once again, surrounded by strange objects which do not yet have a "sense" and thus do not make sense. In "Empire of Signs", Barthes has captured this mood perhaps even better than Martin Heidegger did when he called it the "present at hand".I have only two criticisms for this book, which are minor in comparison to my appreciation for it.
ASTROLOGY: Understanding The Zodiac Signs For Incredible Relationships, Wealth & Wisdom (astrology for the soul, soulmate, horoscope, love astrology, astrological signs) Astrology: Your Complete Guide to Understanding Zodiac Signs: How to Become More Successful, to Improve Your Love Life and Become Happier (Free Bonus Included!) ... (Zodiac, Zodiac Signs, Horoscope Symbols) Numerology: Divination & Numerology: Fortune Telling, Success in Career & Wealth, Love & Relationships, Health & Well Being - Fortune Telling With Numbers ... Runes, Zodiac Signs, Star Signs Book 1) Empire of Signs British & Empire Campaign Medals - Volume 1: 1793 to 1902 (British & Irish/Empire Campaign Medals) The Achaemenid Empire: The First Great Persian Empire Empire, Islam, and Politics of Difference (Ottoman Empire and Its Heritage) Food Signs (Early Sign Language Series) Blood Moons: Decoding the Imminent Heavenly Signs Signs of Our Times Planting By the Signs: Mountain Gardening: The Foxfire Americana Library (10) Epilepsy: Cure - What You Need to Know about Epilepsy: Therapy, Diagnosis, Treatment, Diet, Signs, Symptoms and Medication (Epilepsy Books - Epilepsy Therapy ... Treatment - Epilepsy in children Book 1) ADHD: Parenting a Child or Teen With Attention Deficit Disorder: Signs, Symptoms, Causes & Treatments (Treat ADHD & ADD Without Medication Books) Weight Gain, Asthma, Eczema - Signs of Food Allergies Learn American Sign Language: Everything you need to start signing * complete beginner's guide * 800+ signs The MELT Method: A Breakthrough Self-Treatment System to Eliminate Chronic Pain, Erase the Signs of Aging, and Feel Fantastic in Just 10 Minutes a Day! Understanding Kidney Failure: Everything You Need to Know from Signs, Symptoms and Solutions Reading Between the Signs: Intercultural Communication for Sign Language Interpreters 3rd Edition Reading Between the Signs: Intercultural Communication for Sign Language Interpreters 2nd Edition High Blood Pressure: Know the Causes, Signs, Symptoms and Treatment