Audible Audio Edition
Listening Length: 6 hours and 53 minutes
Program Type: Audiobook
Version: Abridged
Publisher: HighBridge, a division of Recorded Books
Audible.com Release Date: September 19, 2003
Language: English
ASIN: B0000DHYFX
Best Sellers Rank: #22 in Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Philosophy > Movements > Pragmatism #335 in Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Philosophy > Metaphysics #364 in Books > Audible Audiobooks > Nonfiction > Philosophy
"The Metaphysical Club" spent a whole lot of time on bestseller lists, and won a Pulitzer Prize for its author, Louis Menand. Its subtitle, "A Story of Ideas in America," gives some indication on what the book is about, but until you actually read the book you cannot begin to grasp its depth and sheer brilliance. The biggest surprise is Menand's credentials; he is a professor of English at the City University in New York. That an English professor wrote an amazing synthesis of philosophy, sociology, and history is worthy of some type of prize.This book involves the reader on so many different levels that a review is sure to leave lots of information untouched. In short (very short!), Menand argues that studying the philosophical works of Oliver Wendell Holmes, Charles Peirce, William James, and John Dewey will tell us about where America has been, and where it is now. Menand argues that these four people influenced the way we think and act today.Oliver Wendell Holmes fought in the Civil War as a young man. Later in life, he became one of America's leading legal theorists as a justice of the Supreme Court. The war deeply scarred Holmes, calling into question his conceptions of life and truth. In his legal rulings and scholarly articles, Holmes subscribed to the view that "certitude leads to violence," which means those with absolute ideas (like abolitionists and pro-slavery forces) won't compromise their belief systems. The result of this unwillingness to compromise is often bloody violence. Many of Holmes's rulings and writings support the belief that ideas, no matter how repugnant, should find full expression in society regardless of how unworthy they may be.
Both the editorial review and many of the individual reviews have mentioned that this is a study of four principal figures of pragmatism: Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr., William James, Charles Sanders Peirce, and John Dewey. That depiction is, however, incomplete and misleading. THE METAPHYSICAL CLUB is, as the subtitle proclaims, a study of ideas in America. While it is true that these four individuals are the lynchpins around which much of the story revolves, Menand keeps in mind one of the main doctrines held by all these thinkers, that the social is more primary than the individual. This book is a study of the intellectual life of late nineteenth century America as a whole, and while Holmes, James, Sanders, and Dewey provide much of the focus, their individual stories do not exhaust the tale that Menand is trying to tell.Menand provides a brilliant portrait of the intellectual life of America in the post-Civil War era. The story is told from a generalist and not a specialist point of view. If one is interested in pragmatism, this provides the background and an outline of an introduction to the subject. As historical background, this book is unsurpassed. But it is crucial to keep in mind that it is background, not foreground. It does not begin to rival, for instance, such studies as Murry Murphy's tragically out of print study of Peirce's thought, or Gerald Myer's biography of James, or Bruce Kuklick's study of the development of American Philosophy. Apart from the works of the figures themselves, these are the secondary works to which one would go for greater depth on the subject. But none of these works provides Menand's delicious breadth.The number of subjects that Menand takes up is stunning.
The Metaphysical Club Appearance and reality: A metaphysical essay Love is in the Earth: A Kaleidoscope of Crystals - The Reference Book Describing the Metaphysical Properties of the Mineral Kingdom Messages of Hope: The Metaphysical Memoir of a Most Unexpected Medium Annals of the Royal Vancouver Yacht Club 1903-1965: History of the Club's founding; granting of the Royal Charter; prominent early yachtsmen; racing ... and Gulf of Georgia, British Columbia, Canada Club PRISMA / PRISMA Club: Metodo de espanol para jovenes nivel inicial A1 / Spanish Methods for Young Adults Beginners Level A1 (Spanish Edition) Club Abbott: The Deal (Club Abbott Series, #2) Indian club-swinging: one, two, and three club juggling The Faith Club: A Muslim, A Christian, A Jew-- Three Women Search for Understanding The Only One Club Abby's Un-Valentine (The Baby-Sitters Club #127) The Cinnamon Club Cookbook KAHIKI SUPPER CLUB: A Polynesian Paradis (American Palate) Kahiki Supper Club: A Polynesian Paradise in Columbus (American Palate) How to Start a Blog that People Will Read: How to create a website, write about a topic you love, develop a loyal readership, and make six figures doing it. (THE MAKE MONEY FROM HOME LIONS CLUB) CÓMO CREAR UNA PÁGINA WEB O BLOG: con WordPress, sin Código, en su propio dominio, en menos de 2 horas! (THE MAKE MONEY FROM HOME LIONS CLUB) (Spanish Edition) The Augusta National Golf Club; Alister MacKenzie's Masterpiece The Wine Club: A Month-by-Month Guide to Learning About Wine with Friends The Soup Club Cookbook: Feed Your Friends, Feed Your Family, Feed Yourself Simple Foods for the Pack: More than 200 all-natural, trail-tested recipes (Sierra Club Outdoor Adventure Guide)